Heritage Lake sunset with boats on the water

WELCOME TO HERITAGE LAKE

Live the Heritage Lake Life

Discover lake life, homes for sale, boating, fishing, community events and everything that makes Heritage Lake special.

Experience Lake Life

Heritage Lake is a place to get out, explore and enjoy. Here’s a taste of what’s waiting for you.

Boating & Watersports

From quiet pontoon cruises to waterskiing, tubing, wakeboarding, wakesurfing and jet skis, there are plenty of ways to enjoy the water at Heritage Lake.

Explore Boating & Watersports →

Fishing

Cast a line from the dock or take the boat out. Heritage Lake offers excellent fishing year-round.

Explore Fishing →

Beaches & Swimming

Enjoy Heritage Lake’s beaches and swimming areas, with water quality regularly monitored throughout the season.

Explore Amenities →

Pickleball & Recreation

Stay active with pickleball, tennis and recreation throughout the community.

Explore Amenities→

Events & Concerts

Live music, community gatherings, holiday celebrations and lakeside events fill the Heritage Lake calendar.

Explore Events →

Dining & Marina

Grab a bite, dock the boat or enjoy a sunset meal. Dining and marina services right on the water.

Explore Dining & Marina →

Living at Heritage Lake

Everything you want to know before you visit, buy or move in.

The Community

Heritage Lake is a private, deed-restricted community in Coatesville, Indiana with over 1,400 homes, a 500-acre lake and a close-knit neighborhood feel.

Explore →

Lake Rules & Safety

Know before you go. Learn about boating rules, swimming areas, water safety and how Heritage Lake keeps the lake enjoyable for everyone.

Explore →

Buying at Heritage Lake

Waterfront, off-water, cove or main body? Learn what to consider when choosing a Heritage Lake property and what makes buying here different.

Learn More →

Getting Here & Nearby

Heritage Lake is about 45 minutes west of Indianapolis. Find directions, nearby towns, shopping, dining and everything you need close to home.

Explore →

Heritage Lake Real Estate Experience

A sampling of Heritage Lake waterfront homes I’ve helped buyers and sellers successfully close.

I’ve helped more buyers and sellers with Heritage Lake waterfront homes than any other individual REALTOR® since 2017. From quiet coves to main-body properties, that experience gives my clients something a property search can’t: firsthand knowledge of the homes, the shoreline and the Heritage Lake market.

Everything You Need Is Closer Than You Think

One of the first questions buyers ask is, “Where do I go for everything I use now?” From groceries and everyday shopping to home services, boat care and auto needs, you’ll find plenty of familiar conveniences and trusted local businesses within an easy drive of Heritage Lake.

Trusted at Heritage Lake.

Jeremy H.

“Mary helped us understand lake life first, then find a home that fit how we actually live on the water.”

Nancy R.

“As out-of-state buyers, Mary’s videos, maps, and local insights made Heritage Lake feel familiar before we ever visited.”

Tim B.

“Mary knows which coves are quiet, where kids gather to swim, and how the community really works day to day.”

What Residents Love About Heritage Lake

Andy M.

“What I love most about Heritage Lake is the unique culture and sense of community that comes with living here. There’s always something to do, and so much of life revolves around our beautiful, private lake—from boating and fishing to time with neighbors, family, and friends. It truly feels like a special community and a lifestyle you don’t find in many other places.”

Rick M.

“The easy and truest answer is everything because there is so much to love.

If I’m forced to be specific about 1 thing, I’d have to say the genuine sense of community.  We are all united by our common interest, the lake and everything around it.  While that is true, I moved my family 17 times before we landed here and in all that time I never felt the sense of community I feel here.

In all my years here, I’ve never seen a call for help go unanswered.”

Carolyn M.

“We love the scenic views, pristine water, evening lake cruises, watching and sharing in the fun and frolic on the lake, the peacefulness of a rainy day, concerts, Feast n Ski and other community events, and meeting friends and neighbors at Sahm’s. The wildlife at Heritage Lake is abundant and entertaining, from watching eagles fly and osprey dive for fish to the abundant and beautiful deer.”

REALTOR · RESOURCE · RESIDENT

Your Heritage Lake Realtor, Resource & Resident.

Mary Petruzzi has called Heritage Lake home since 2008. As a longtime Realtor and active community volunteer, she knows the lake, the homes, and the lifestyle firsthand — not from a sales sheet, but from years of living it. Whether you’re looking to buy, sell, or simply learn what life here is really like, Mary brings local knowledge that goes well beyond the MLS.

She’s guided buyers through their first waterfront purchase, helped longtime residents find their next chapter, and spent years volunteering within the community she loves. When you work with Mary, you get someone who’s been here, knows everyone, and genuinely cares about the fit — not just the transaction.

Contact Mary

Reach out to plan a visit, ask lake-life questions, or talk through your Heritage Lake home plans.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Let’s Talk Heritage Lake

Thinking about making Heritage Lake home?
Whether you’re curious about homes for sale, off-market opportunities, or simply have questions about life at the lake, I’m happy to help.

Mary Petruzzi, REALTOR®
Heritage Lake Realtor, Resource & Resident
RE/MAX One
317-370-5509
Mary@TeamPetruzzi.com